Holy Father's Letter to the Bishops of the U.S.A.
The faithful of North America have been shocked and saddened by news about some members of the clergy being guilty of serious sins of the flesh committed against some people.
Jesus said, "Watch and pray that you enter not into temptation." We must be vigilant and pray for ourselves and others that we also not become victims of the devil "who goes about like a roaring lion seeking someone to devour" as St. Peter writes in Sacred Scripture. By the grace of God we have not fallen victim but as St. Philip Neri used to often say in all truth and humility, "There but for the grace of God go I."
It is terrible that these sins have been committed but it is also with a sense of our own humble condition and need of God's grace that we report these facts, mindful that we should not be proud of not having fallen lest God allow us to fall to heal our pride. But it is also necessary that we address the issues publicly lest anyone be led astray by our silence. For more reasons why we must speak out, see pg.6.
We must condemn these sins publicly while we pray to Our Heavenly Mother, the Queen of the Clergy to preserve all priests in grace and to convert sinners.
His Holiness has recently expressed his grave concern about these scandals to the Bishops of the United States. His letter to them published here below in its entirety was published in the English edition of the newspaper of the Vatican L'Osservatore Romano 6/30/93.
Venerable and Dear Brother Bishops of the United States
"Woe to the world because of scandals!" (Matthew 18:7).
During these last months I have become aware of how much you, the Pastors of the Church in the United States, together with all the faithful, are suffering because of certain cases of scandal given by members of the clergy. During the ad limina visits many times the conversation has turned to this problem of how the sins of clerics have shocked the moral sensibilities of many and become an occasion of sin for others. The Gospel word "woe" has a special meaning, especially when Christ applies it to cases of scandal, and first of all to the scandal "of the little ones" (cf. Matthew 18:6). How severe are Christ's words when He speaks of such scandal, how great must be that evil if "for him who gives scandal it would be better to have a great millstone hung around his neck and to be drowned in the depths of the sea" (cf. Matthew 18:6).
The vast majority of Bishops and priests are devoted followers of Christ, ardent workers in His vineyard, and men who are deeply sensitive to the needs of their brothers and sisters. That is why I am deeply pained, like you, when it seems that the words of Christ can be applied to some ministers of the altar. Since Christ calls them His "friends" (cf. John 15:15), their sin - the sin of giving scandal to the innocent - must pain His heart indeed. Therefore, I fully share your sorrow and your concern, especially your concern for the victims so seriously hurt by these misdeeds.
Every sinner who follows the way of repentance, conversion and pardon can call on the mercy of God, and you in particular must encourage and assist those who stray to be reconciled and find peace of conscience. There is also the question of the human means for responding to this evil. The canonical penalties which are provided for certain offenses and which give a social expression of disapproval for the evil are fully justified. These help to maintain a clear distinction between good and evil, and contribute to moral behavior as well as to creating a proper awareness of the gravity of the evil involved. As you are aware, a joint committee of experts from the Holy See and the Bishops' Conference has just been established to study how the universal canonical norms can best be applied to the particular situation of the United States.
I would also draw your attention to another aspect of the whole question. While acknowledging the right to due freedom of information, one cannot acquiesce in treating moral evil as an occasion for sensationalism. Public opinion often feeds on sensationalism and the mass media play a particular role therein. In fact, the search for sensationalism leads to the loss of something which is essential to the morality of society. Harm is done to the fundamental right of individuals not to be easily exposed to the ridicule of public opinion; even more, a distorted image of human life is created. Moreover, by making a moral offense the object of sensationalism, without reference to the dignity of human conscience, one acts in a direction which is in fact opposed to the pursuit of the moral good. There is already sufficient proof that the prevalence of violence and impropriety in the mass media has become a source of scandal. Evil can indeed be sensational, but the sensationalism surrounding it is always dangerous for morality.
Therefore, the words of Christ about scandal apply also to all those persons and institutions, often anonymous, that through sensationalism in various ways open the door to evil in the conscience and behavior of vast sectors of society, especially among the young who are particularly vulnerable. "Woe to the world because of scandals!" Woe to societies where scandal becomes an everyday event.
So then, venerable brothers, you are faced with two levels of serious responsibility: in relation to the clerics through whom scandal comes and their innocent victims, but also in relation to the whole of society systematically threatened by scandal and responsible for it. A great effort is needed to halt the trivializing of the great things of God and man.
I ask you to reflect together with the priests, who are your co-workers, and with the laity, and to respond with all the means at your disposal. Among these means, the first and most important is prayer: ardent, humble, confident prayer. This whole sad question must be placed in a context which is not exclusively human; it must be freed from being considered commonplace. Prayer makes us aware that everything - even evil - finds its principal and definitive reference point in God. In Him every sinner can be raised up again. In this way sin will not become an unfortunate cause of sensationalism, but rather the occasion for an interior call, as Christ has said: "Repent" (Matthew 4:17). "The Lord is near" (Philippians 4:5).
Yes, dear brothers, America needs much prayer - lest it lose its soul. We are one in this prayer, remembering the words of the Redeemer: "Watch and pray, that you may not enter into temptation" (Mark 14:38). Christ the Good Shepherd calls us to this attitude when He says, "Take courage, I have overcome the world" (John 16:33). United with you in the firm trust that our Savior is ever faithful in caring for His People and that He will not fail to give you the strength to fulfill your pastoral ministry, I commend the clergy, religious and lay faithful of your Dioceses to the loving intercession of His Immaculate Mother Mary. With fraternal affection in Christ Jesus, I impart my Apostolic Blessing.
From the Vatican, June 11, 1993
Joannes Paulus II
Table of Contents